| 2011 |
- Female Athlete Kristen Landry, James Madison, Cross Country
- Male Athlete Greg Cuccinello, Towson, Lacrosse
- Male Scholar Athlete Tim Labeau, Tufts, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Carly Gneiwick, Cornell, Lacrosse
|
| 2010 |
- Female Athlete Erin Turlot, Rutgers
- Male Athlete Kevin Ryan, Loyola, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Leslie Kang, Gallaudet
- Male Scholar Athlete Tim Shaw, Lafayette
|
| 2009 |
- Female Athlete Jordan Renna, Yale
- Male Athlete Chase Winter, Johns Hopkins, Lacrosse
- Male Athlete Jake Tripuka, Duke, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Amanda Solch, Bates
- Male Scholar Athlete Kevin Rankin, UVA
|
| 2008 |
- Female Athlete Caroline Dewing, Yale, Swimming
- Male Athlete Mark Dobrosky, Yale, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Kaytlena Stillman, U Penn, Swimming
- Male Scholar Athlete Dillon Hamill, Haverford , Lacrosse
|
| 2007 |
- Female Athlete Sally Ryan, Middlebury
- Male Athlete Jesse Cohen, Naval Academy
- Female Scholar Athlete Meredith Aronson, Colby
- Male Scholar Athlete Jakob Jurgensen, Columbia
|
| 2006 |
- Female Athlete Tracy Deitrick, Syracuse, Field Hockey
- Male Athlete Austin Winter, Bucknell, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Alisha Carrazza, Holy Cross, Swimming
- Male Scholar Athlete Bob Steinhauser, Stevens, Lacrosse
|
| 2005 |
- Female Athlete Kate McWilliams, Marist, Lacrosse
- Male Athlete Chris Ryan, Villanova, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Hannah Simon, Dartmouth, Field Hockey
- Male Scholar Athlete Judd Cramer, Northwestern, Football
|
| 2004 |
- Female Athlete Katie Chambers, Williams, Swimming
- Male Athlete Paul Chiara. Syracuse, Football
- Female Scholar Athlete Julia Sweeney
- Male Scholar Athlete Matt Gotilla
|
| 2003 |
- Female Athlete Kristen McWilliams, Boston Univ
- Male Athlete Ryan Kielty, Villanova
- Female Scholar Athlete Christine Dobrosky, Princeton, Lacrosse
- Scholar Athlete Brian Platt, Emory Univ. Track & Field
|
| 2002 |
- Female Athlete Lindsay Munday, Northwestern, Lacrosse
- Male Athlete Michael Moran, Lehigh, Lacrosse
- Female Scholar Athlete Tricia Chambers, Williams, Swimming
- Male Scholar Athlete Paul Fetch, Georgetown, Club Soccer
|
